Tuesday, January 25, 2011

Investopedia: McDonald's Seems A Bit Overcooked

Quality is all well and good, but at some point price always has to matter. That, then, is the issue with McDonald's (NYSE:MCD) shares today - there is really no quibbling over the quality of the company, but have investors already baked in more than enough optimism? 

The Quarter that Was
The fourth quarter was really not a performance that McDonald's management is going to tack onto the board as a prototype. Revenue grew 4% (5% in constant currency) and met estimates, and full-quarter comp growth of 5% was not all that bad. More problematic, though, is the trend in those comps. December comps were a bit soft, rising 3.7% versus 4.8% in November. U.S. comps slipped below 3% in December, while Europe went negative. Although the company pointed towards weather as a key issue in the U.S. and Europe numbers, and management is still looking for 4 to 5% growth in 2011, institutional investors can be a twitchy and unforgiving lot.

Going down the earnings statement, the company appeared to have a relatively lower-quality quarter. Operating income grew 2% as reported (or 3% in constant currency) and the company clearly lost some of its operating leverage. What's more, while the company met estimates for the period, it got a boost from more favorable taxes and would have missed the quarter otherwise. (For more, See Zooming In On Operating Income.)

The Road Ahead
For a company of its size, McDonald's has done an impressive job of growing its free cash flow over the past five or six years. Moreover, the company has navigated the recession better than many other restaurant operators. Some of that is due to new store hours and menu items (particularly the value meal options), while some of it is also due to the quality-value trade-off that customers see in McDonald's menu (nutritionists may hate it, but customers like it).


Please follow this link for the full piece:
http://stocks.investopedia.com/stock-analysis/2011/McDonalds-Seems-A-Bit-Overcooked-MCD-YUM-CMG-JACK-SONC-PNRA-WEN0125.aspx

No comments: